it is all a mater of opinion dude, it doesn't matter what critics say or even if 99% of the world hated a game...if I like the game that is all that matters, I will still play it. I see nothing wrong with it; a single critic's views is meaningless, a critic once called star wars crap and titanic amazing...that shows how bad their judgment can be. when MANY critics sya the same thing I might agree, because then that shows that numerous opinions thought the same thing...but that isn't the case.
what exactly failed is of little interest to me, it was a good game and connected with the films perfectly. the only other alien game that comes close to it is AVP (the one where you could play the predator, marine or alien storyline that crossed paths...which was an ok game but had frustrating control systems and didn't enable you to really kill like a true Predator that was NEVER seen, but it did introduce Combat Androids which was an awesome illegal tech of Weyland Yutani).
how about instead of bickering that it was wrong and crap you tell me how it was wrong, give examples, because saying something "just was" is basically like saying you hate something without giving a reason, it is stupid, give a reason then it is fair enough.